Without a Net 2 or Crowding out Satisfaction

In the previous post, Ombudsben‘s comment got me thinking that there was a lot more to say here. He referred to how creatures flock in groups to escape predators and that not only does this make you one of many rather than one out of one but that its not uncommon that this so flusters the predator that they come away empty mouthed. Just like me hunting clothing. I recently walked out of a store because I just had too many decisions to make (I must confess here that shopping for clothing for me is one of the clearest manifestations of hell).

But consider that in one case there is a purpose to the crowding to avoid capture and in the other hand the proliferation of choice is supposed to result in greater sales. Somebody wasn’t paying attention on the way up the evolutionary ladder it seems. A recent article in the NYT about happiness said that it had declined in China since 1994 when in the same period average real incomes grew by 250%. In the United States there was no measured increase in happiness between 1944 and 1974 despite the general increase in wealth.


So when I grew up I had and enjoyed Heinz catsup.


(Photo courtesy of Patrick: source: http://www.flickr.com/photos/o_caritas/4787872/)

Since then there have been hundreds of catsup (or ketchup) brought onto the market. What is in my fridge right now? A year old bottle of Heinz. Now I don’t really use the stuff anymore; I’ve become a salsa man and I did have a dalliance with the short lived hot Heinz catsup since I had already been mixing mine with sambal oelek to give it some zing but the point is, I’ve still got the same old stuff. When I tried the hot version it was just before the catsup explosion happened and I just might never have made that brave move if that would have been the sequence of events.

All the Chinese and Americans now have increased access to condiments of all kinds and it doesn’t seem to have made much of a difference. I know that also it is an axiom of childrearing to provide a choice between two clear alternatives rather than “what would you like for dinner?” Its much easier to answer whether I would like a whiskey or a beer than be faced with an extensive bar and have to think of some sort of mixed drink. And as pleasing as that brandy alexander or whatever might be, the difference in real happiness in my system between that and the beer would be minimal. I do confess that I am particular in my drinks and would have asked what kind of beer and what kind of whiskey. Which leads to the next conundrum.

Presenting choices introduces dissatisfaction where before there was none. It implies that what you have is not the best. It implies that you have an imperfect knowledge of the world of condiments and that to be a fully realized human being you better get on board that bus. Now a secondary issue arises; the bus will not guarantee to take you as far as you may need to go. The more products there are. the more likely it is that any of them will be discontinued. My hot Heinz fell to the wayside to be replaced by another Heinz tinged with Tabasco, and though I do like heat I do not like the taste of Tobasco. Ergo, my happiness level fell until I got over catsup entirely.

Would I prefer a world with fewer choices? Though I have ended up with a couple of things I would now miss, most of them come from areas in which the general quality had been low, not where there had been a lack of choice. There’s always been coffee but it has gotten a lot better. In most cases, something was not bad and all thats been done is to create varieties for the reason of interest rather than taste. All in all, I am for the restriction of choice in products. Life is too short to spend so much of it standing in an aisle looking at 1800 types of crackers. Besides you could make an argument that this proliferation of crap is the work of the wizards trying to keep us from looking behind the curtain.

8 comments on “Without a Net 2 or Crowding out Satisfaction

  1. I think you have a real point about extra choice not producing higher levels of satisfaction. On the other hand, I think there are more high quality products available than before. Would they be missed if they weren’t there? Probably not. I’m torn on this issue.

  2. I think you have a real point about extra choice not producing higher levels of satisfaction. On the other hand, I think there are more high quality products available than before. Would they be missed if they weren’t there? Probably not. I’m torn on this issue.

  3. Were your comments forming a crowd to reduce the possibility of deletion?

  4. LOL! I have no idea how that happened. Perhaps you could delete one? Or leave them both if you like, since your comment is so a propos.

  5. When I toured Europe in ’85 I went out of my way to talk to Europeans, and there were 2 common myths about “the states” (as we are known).

    The first was the return of the “rich uncle” from America who would come home to their European town and sprinkle gold around.

    The second was about going to an American market and seeing all the types of bread on the shelf.(I heard this in Italy, Sweden, and Finland.) In Italy the woman told me she cried; and in Sweden too the story was of being overwhelmed by the options.

    Only the gypsy Finn cried out *against* the myth: “what do I care how many types of bread there are!? How many types of hunger does one have?”

    Besides, the diving falcon has only one hunger–and the confusion of the flock in the split second of its decision deprives him of slaking even the that solitary diving drive.


  6. How many types of hunger…that’s good.

  7. Dude…

    Photographs on my flickr site are not for the taking. Not only did you use this photo without permission, but didn’t even bother to attribute it. Please remove it.

    Thank you.
    Patrick T. Power

  8. My apologies Patrick….all fixed now as per our discussion.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: